Best Fruit Butters In December 2022

Looking for some of the apple butter brand? As you may know, there are dozens of brands available in the market such as Green Jay Gourmet,Stonewall Kitchen and some come with vastly different price tags. Let us help you out here – we have handpicked for you the best apple butter brand.

To compile our list of the best apple butter brand, we've researched and evaluated a range of the best-selling apple butter brand on the market. We recommend Green Jay Gourmet Apple Butter Brand as our top pick because of its best overall performance. Want to explore more options? Read on! There's also a buying guide to help you make a wise shopping decision.

Editor's Choice
Hearth and Pantry Apple Butter Spread - Salted Caramel Apple Fruit Butter - Gluten Free -
9.7
Hearth and Pantry Apple Butter Spread - Salted Caramel Apple Fruit Butter - Gluten Free -
Premium Pick
Green Jay Gourmet Monkey Butter - All-Natural, Gluten-Free Banana Butter - Pineapple Spread with
9.4
Green Jay Gourmet Monkey Butter - All-Natural, Gluten-Free Banana Butter - Pineapple Spread with
Budget Pick
Dillman Farm Fruit Butter Variety Pack (6 pack)| Apple Butter, Pumpkin Butter, No Sugar Added
9.1
Dillman Farm Fruit Butter Variety Pack (6 pack)| Apple Butter, Pumpkin Butter, No Sugar Added

Top 10 Best Fruit Butters Reviews 2022

1. Hearth and Pantry Apple Butter Spread - Salted Caramel Apple Fruit Butter - Gluten Free -

  • DECADENT & DIVINE: You're in for a Treat! When Salted Caramel Meets Apple Butter It's a Perfect Match! Slather on Your Morning Toast, Add to Biscuits, Scones, and Pastries. This Thick, Rich Caramel Butter Has Just the Right Amount of Sweetness.
  • HANDCRAFTED IN SMALL BATCHES: Our Fruit Butters Are All Handmade in Small Batches, in An Allergen-Free Facility. Keeping Our Batches Small Means, We Never Compromise on Quality, Ensuring We Deliver You Premium Products Each and Every Time You Order.
  • TRADITIONAL AMISH RECIPE: Our Apple Butter Is Based on An Old Amish Recipe That Uses Real Apple Cider to Create a Sweet Spread, Bursting with Apple Flavor. Our Fruit Butters Are Made the Old-Fashioned Way: Cooked Down and Reduced in a Large Kettle to Concentrate the Flavor and Make the Perfect Apple Butter for Toast, Biscuits and More.
  • JUST-PICKED FLAVORS YEAR-ROUND: Hearth and Pantry Quality Canned Goods Are Based on Our Favorite Classic Canning Recipes of Yesteryear. Our Jams Are Meticulously Prepared, Just Like Our Grandparents Taught Us. Stock Your Shelves with Our Fruit Butter, and You Can Enjoy Your Favorite Just-Picked Flavors Year-Round!
  • 100% NATURAL INGREDIENTS: Our Apple Butter Is Carefully Crafted with the Finest All-Natural Ingredients to Ensure Every Jar Is Bursting with Exceptional Freshness and Bold, Fruit-Forward Flavor. No Preservatives. No Artificial Flavors. Just Simple Ingredients You've Actually Heard Of!

2. Green Jay Gourmet Monkey Butter - All-Natural, Gluten-Free Banana Butter - Pineapple Spread with

Green Jay Gourmet Monkey Butter - All-Natural, Gluten-Free Banana Butter - Pineapple Spread with
9.8
By - Green Jay Gourmet
  • FOR YOU, NOTHING BUT THE BEST: Like All Our Products, Green Jay Gourmet Fruit Butter & Fruit Spread Varieties Are Made From Responsibly Sourced, Premium Ingredients; Cooked Carefully in Small Batches; Banana Butter Made in the USA
  • ALL-NATURAL, GLUTEN FREE: All Green Jay Gourmet Fruit Butter Flavors Use All-Natural, Real Food Ingredients; Naturally Gluten-Free, Trans-Fat Free; Our Fruit Butters & Fruit Spreads Contain No Corn Syrup, Preservatives Or MSG; Contains Sugar
  • PLAYFULLY DELECTABLE: The Green Jay Gourmet Monkey Butter Is More Than Just a Banana Butter Or Pineapple Spread; Creamy, Fruity, Gourmet Fruit Butter with the Goodness of Sweet Bananas, Tropical Pineapple & Rich Mango
  • THE BETTER BUTTER: Green Jay Gourmet Fruit Butters Bring to You the Familiar, Comforting Butter Experience with a Whole Lot of Fruity, Unique Flavors You Won't Find Elsewhere; Fruit Spreads That Can Deliciously Replace the Same-Old, Boring Butter
  • BUTTER YOUR FAVORITE FOODS UP: The Monkey Butter, with Its Rich Flavor Profile, Is a Perfect Addition to Your Favorite Foods, From Crumble Bars & Grilled Chicken to Cinnamon Rolls & Croissants; Click ‘Add to Cart' to Order a 19 Oz. Jar Right Away

3. Dillman Farm Fruit Butter Variety Pack (6 pack)| Apple Butter, Pumpkin Butter, No Sugar Added

  • CLEAN INGREDIENTS – Our Fruit Butters Always Have Real Fruit As the Number One Ingredient! This Contains No Corn Syrups, GMOs, Or Gluten
  • TASTES LIKE GRANDMA MADE IT - One Whiff of Any of Our Fruit Butters and You Will Immediately Be Reminded of the Smell of Grandma's Kitchen When She Made Homemade Apple Butter
  • MADE IN THE USA- In An Allergen Free, Safe Quality Food Certified Facility
  • SHARE WITH FRIENDS - Our Fruit Butter Variety Pack Makes An Amazing Housewarming Gift
  • FRUIT BUTTER VARIETY PACK - Featuring Apple Butter, Cherry Butter, Organic Apple Butter, Peach Butter, Pear Butter & Pumpkin Butter

4. Stonewall Kitchen Our Fruit Butter Collection (3 pc)

Stonewall Kitchen Our Fruit Butter Collection (3 pc)
9.8
By - Stonewall Kitchen
  • Creamy, Smooth and Rich in Flavor, Each One Is Great As a Topping on Breakfast Breads, Muffins, Toast Or Scones Or Can Be Used in Baking
  • Includes Fig & Walnut Butter (12.75 Oz), Maple Pumpkin Butter (12.25 Oz), and Caramel Apple Butter (12.5 Oz)
  • It All Started in 1991 At a Local Farmers' Market with a Few Dozen Items That We'd Finished Hand-Labeling Only Hours Before. Fast-Forward to Today and Stonewall Kitchen Is Now Home to An Ever-Growing Family of Like-Minded Lifestyle Brands! Expertly Made with Premium Ingredients, Our Products Are the Result of Decades Spent Dreaming Up, Testing and Producing Only the Very Best in Specialty Foods and Fine Home Living.
  • Great As a Topping on Breakfast Breads, Muffins, Toast Or Scones
  • Stonewall Kitchen Our Fruit Butter Collection (3 Pc)

5. Smuckers Fruit Butter Apple Cider

  • Tastes Glorious on Toast, Bakes Wonderfully in Cakes, & Glazes Pork to Perfection.
  • For More Than 100 Years, Smuckers Has Been Making Life More Fruitful by Bringing You Delicious Fruit Spreads and Smiles.
  • Made by Slowly Cooking Fruit & Sugar Together Until a Smooth, Thick "butter-Like" Consistency Emerges.
  • Perfect Combination of Old-Time Sweetness and Rich Texture.
  • 3 - 16.5oz. CIDER APPLE BUTTER by Smuckers

6. Peach Butter, 18 oz

  • Taste the Fruit in Every Bite!
  • No Artificial Ingredients
  • Apply Generously to a Hot Biscuit, Toast Or Pancakes. A Delicious Taste of Spring.
  • Peaches, Sugar, Cinnamon, Cloves, Allspice.
  • Produced in Amish Country Where Quality Is a Way of Life

7. Amish Fruit Butters (Two 16 oz. Jars) (Apple Butter)

Amish Fruit Butters (Two 16 oz. Jars) (Apple Butter)
9.8
By - The Amish-Buggy
  • All Butters Are Non GMO
  • All Natural with No Artificial Preservatives
  • Amish Made in Small Batches Not in Large Factories Claiming to Be Made by the Amish

8. Tennessee's Best Old Fashion Apple Butter - All Natural, Fruit in a Jar, Slow-Cooked - Small Batch -

Tennessee's Best Old Fashion Apple Butter - All Natural, Fruit in a Jar, Slow-Cooked - Small Batch -
9.8
By - Tennessee's Best
  • All Natural, No Preservatives, and No High Fructose Corn Syrup
  • Resealable Glass Jars
  • Handcrafted to Maintain the Flavor of the Apples and Spices

9. Kauffman's Fruit Farm Homemade Apple Butter Spread, Maroon Label (No Granulated Sugar Added Recipe),

Kauffman's Fruit Farm Homemade Apple Butter Spread, Maroon Label (No Granulated Sugar Added Recipe),
9.8
By - Kauffman's Fruit Farm & Market
  • Use on Toast, Bagels, Butter Bread, and Ice Cream
  • Old-Fashioned Cooking Process Uses Kauffman Homemade Sweet Apple Cider and Creates a Rich, Delicious Flavor (no Commercial Additives Or Preservatives)
  • Made in the USA; Brown Label Apple Butter Is Kauffman's No Granulated Sugar Added Recipe
  • Homemade At Kauffman's Fruit Farm in Small Batches with Simple Ingredients: Fresh Apples, Fresh-Pressed Apple Cider, and Cinnamon
  • Eat to Your Health; Buy in Bulk and Save!

10. Gourmet Lilikoi Butter, Passion Fruit Butter, Made in Hawaii, Dip into Paradise, 7.5 oz

Gourmet Lilikoi Butter, Passion Fruit Butter, Made in Hawaii, Dip into Paradise, 7.5 oz
9.8
By - Dip Into Paradise
  • Pairs Perfectly with Toast, Pancakes, Tarts, & Cheesecake.
  • Gourmet Lilikoi Butter.
  • Made with Fresh Lilikoi.
  • A Delectable Island Treat.
  • Made in Hawaii.

Frequently Asked Question

1. How long do fruit butters last?

Fruit butters will last for one to two weeks in the refrigerator but they can also be frozen, using freezer-safe packaging. Some fruit butters can also be preserved using the water bath canning method.

2. What kind of fruit butters are there?

Popular types of fruit butter include:. Apple butter.Pear butter.Pumpkin butter.Peach butter.Plum butter.Fig butter.Apple butter.,Pear butter.,Pumpkin butter.,Peach butter.,Plum butter.,Fig butter.,

3. What do you do with fruit butters?

We love fruit butters!Use in recipes in lieu of sugar in an apple crisp or applesauce.,Mix 1 part butter spread to 1 part maple syrup for French toast and pancakes.,Mix it into roasted or baked sweet potatoes.,Use butter spreads and pecans as crepe filling.,Spread it on toast or English muffins instead of jelly.,

4. What's the difference between fruit preserves and fruit butter?

Butters: Butters are made from pureed fruit. They are not as sweet as preserves, jams, or jellies but offer a full fruit flavor. Butters are cooked for over 6 hours ,at a low temperature, allowing the product to thicken. Butters tend to be dark because of the exposure to air during the cooking.